Revisiting the Planetary Nebulae Discovered by the IRAS Satellite

Launched in 1983, the Infrared Astronomical Satellite (IRAS) revolutionized infrared astronomy as the first satellite to survey the entire sky at infrared (IR) wavelengths. During its 10-month mission, IRAS mapped the sky at 12-100 µm, catalogued >350,000 infrared sources (including debris disks and active galaxies), mapped Solar System zodiacal dust structures (including previously-undiscovered dust bands [Sykes & Greenberg, 1986]), and plus discovered ten small bodies (e.g. (3200) Phaethon and C/1983 H1). Less often highlighted is IRAS’s major contribution to the study and detection of planetary nebulae (PNe) and post-AGB stars. Not only did IRAS ultimately lead to the detection of more than forty PNe (and several PPNe), but they are historically significant as the first generation of PN and post-AGB stars discovered using satellite data. In particular, the catalogue of Dr. Andrea Preite-Martinez (1988) is discussed here, with various pretty examples shown in Fig. 1.

Fig. 1: Compilation of various Pan-STARRS1 image extracts showing confirmed Planetary Nebulae discovered by Dr. Andrea Preite-Martinez (1988) through systematically studying the IRAS point source catalogue. Though the majority of these PNe are young PNe that are relatively compact and difficult to resolve in current survey imagery, some display well-resolved circular, elliptical or bipolar morphologies with resolvable central stars. Image credit: Legacy Survey Sky Browser.

As most PNe lie along the dust-obscured Galactic plane, IRAS offered a major advantage over other surveys at the time, not only at detecting their intrinsic IR emissions through interstellar dust (e.g. Preite-Martinez, 1987,1988), but also at better distinguishing PNe from certain other Radio-emitting objects such as HII regions (Preite-Martinez, 1987,1988). In the case of PNe, Mid-Far-IR emissions arise from the star-heated dust released during the late-AGB phase, as well as from various emissions lines, including atomic (e.g. [Ar III], [N III], [S IV], [O IV]), and molecular (e.g. Si-O stretching, in the case of O-rich PNe). Though IRAS was equipped with a low resolution IR spectrometer (Pottasch et al., 1986), the selection criteria for the IRAS/Preite-Martinez PNe were purely photometric, and were defined according to already-known PNe, HII regions, OH/IR stars and YSOs: F(12)/F25) ≤ 0.35 and F(25)/F(60) ≥ 0.35 (e.g. IRAS 19084+0422 a.k.a. PM 1-285, Fig. 2). Preite-Martinez further divided their candidates into two sub-catalogues: “PM 1-X,” considered more likely to be true PNe based on their SEDs, and “PM 2-X,” considered less likely. Indeed, all PNe in Fig. 1 are part of the former list.

Fig. 2: An example of an IRAS planetary nebula (IRAS 19084+0422, a.k.a. PM 1-285) as seen in the different IRAS filters. IRAS is observing the dust being heated by the central star and being re-emitted in the infrared. Image credit: IRAS/ISSA, NASA/IPAC Infrared Science Archive, which is funded by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and operated by the California Institute of Technology.

Sources meeting these criteria were flagged as “Possible PNe,” requiring follow-up observations (particularly optical spectroscopy: e.g., Suárez et al., 2006), for confirmation. Such observations can be challenging because, despite being bright at mid- to far-IR wavelengths, many candidates are optically faint due to interstellar extinction. At the time, available optical-IR imagery was also generally insufficient to resolve their morphologies. Modern surveys such as DECaPS and Pan-STARRS now reveal elliptical, bipolar, and circular structures among these objects, although most remain unresolved (i.e. “stellar”, such as IRAS 18524+0544, a.k.a. PM 1-264) (Fig. 1).

However, IRAS-detectable PNe partially overlap photometrically in the far-IR colors with some evolved (post-)AGB stars (e.g. Pottasch et al., 1988). In fact, follow-up studies of systematic IRAS PN searches (Pottasch et al., 1988; Preite-Martinez, 1988) uncovered not only very young, compact, dusty PNe (including some that turned out to be “OHPNe”: Cala et al., 2025), but also potential transitional objects such as proto-planetary nebulae (PPNe) (Sahai et al., 2005; Suarez et al., 2006), further helping bridge the AGB-PN transition. This is because the dusty circumstellar envelope [that leads to the bright IR signal] originates in the AGB-phase and is present (though progressively dissipating) through the PPN and PN phase, implying that late-AGB, PPN and young PNe practically share similar dust IR emissions.

Fig. 3: Compilation of various DECaPS2 and Pan-STARRS1 image extracts of objects discovered by Dr. Andrea Preite-Martinez (1988) through systematically studying the IRAS point source catalogue for PNe. Though many objects were deemed true PNe, others were found to be OH/IR stars and intermediate members such as PPNe. Image credit: Legacy Survey Sky Browser.

To this day, many objects initially listed by Preite-Martinez (1988) remain unconfirmed as PNe by optical spectroscopy. Among them are the three objects in Fig. 4, all currently classified as “Possible PNe” in HASH. IRAS 18430−0636 (PM 1-256) appears as a compact, green stellar source in Pan-STARRS1 g+r+i images, similar to other young, compact PNe from Preite-Martinez (1988). The green colour likely traces nebular Hα emission in the PS1 r band, also supported by SHS Hα images. A possible weak NVSS radio counterpart, potentially tracing thermal free–free emission, further supports its nature as an emission object. IRAS 18415−1945 (PM 1-254) appears more evolved, showing a ~50″ circular nebula in SHS Hα images surrounding a blue central star, consistent with a circular PN and its CSPN.

Fig. 4: Compilation of various survey image extracts of three objects from Preite-Martinez (1988) that lack confirmation in regards to their PN nature. While IRAS 18430-0636 and IRAS 18415-1945 have good chances of being true PNe, IRAS 17555-3621 may be a PPN. Image credit: Legacy Survey Sky Browser, HASH database and SIMBAD.

In contrast, IRAS 17555−3621 (PM 1-196) lacks evident Hα and NVSS radio emission. However, DECaPS2 images reveal a central yellow source surrounded by bipolar blue nebulosity apparently unreported in the literature. These characteristics suggest a bipolar reflection nebula and potentially a previously unidentified PPN. Follow-up spectroscopy is required to establish its nature.

References

Cala, R. A., Gómez, J. F., Miranda, L. F., Imai, H., Anglada, G., de Gregorio-Monsalvo, I., … & Uscanga, L. (2025). Identification and characterization of nascent planetary nebulae with OH and H2O masers. Astronomy & Astrophysics, 703, A268.

Sykes, M. V., & Greenberg, R. (1986). The formation and origin of the IRAS zodiacal dust bands as a consequence of single collisions between asteroids. Icarus, 65(1), 51-69.

Pottasch, S. R., Preite-Martinez, A., Olnon, F. M., Mo, J. E., & Kingma, S. (1986). IRAS spectra planetary nebulae. III. Astronomy and Astrophysics (ISSN 0004-6361), vol. 161, no. 2, June 1986, p. 363-375., 161, 363-375.

Preite-Martinez, A. (1987). Search for possible planetary nebulae in the IRAS Point Source Catalog-Selection criteria. In CNR, National Conference on Infrared Astronomy, 2nd, Vulcano, Italy, Sept. 14-18, 1987 Società Astronomica Italiana, Memorie (ISSN 0037-8720), vol. 58, no. 2-3, 1987, p. 223-226. (Vol. 58, pp. 223-226).

Preite-Martinez, A. (1988). Possible new planetary nebulae in the IRAS point source catalogue. Astronomy and Astrophysics Supplement Series (ISSN 0365-0138), vol. 76, no. 3, Dec. 1988, p. 317-330., 76, 317-330.

Sahai, R., Le Mignant, D., Sánchez Contreras, C., Campbell, R. D., & Chaffee, F. H. (2005). Sculpting a Pre-planetary Nebula with a Precessing Jet: IRAS 16342–3814. The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 622(1), L53-L56.

Suárez, O., García-Lario, P., Manchado, A., Manteiga, M., Ulla, A., & Pottasch, S. R. (2006). A spectroscopic atlas of post-AGB stars and planetary nebulae selected from the IRAS point source catalogue. Astronomy & Astrophysics, 458(1), 173-180.

This blog post also makes use of the The University of Hong Kong/Australian Astronomical Observatory/Strasbourg Observatory H-alpha Planetary Nebula (HASH PN) database, the Legacy Survey Sky Browser and the NASA/IPAC Infrared Science Archive.

Comets in the Sun’s Glare: Activity in the Daytime Sky!

Coronagraphs allow astronomers to observe regions of the sky extremely close to the Sun, revealing comets that would otherwise be lost in its glare. Most of these objects are intrinsically small, that only flare-up close to the Sun, and then are never observed again. This is the case of the vast majority of comets found at low solar elongation. In fact, previously unknown comets are caught close-to-daily by amateur astronomers diligently surveying real-time data from GOES-19, SOHO and even STEREO. Although much of the attention has understandably focused on C/2026 A1 (MAPS), it’s easy to overlook just how dynamic the near-Sun environment is in terms of comets. In anticipation of C/2026 A1 (MAPS), here’s a look at several recently discovered near-Sun comets, along with my own opinions on how C/2026 A1 may ultimately evolve.

A Sungrazer, Planets and CMEs!

On January 18th, a moderately-bright Kreutz-group comet was reported in real-time SOHO/LASCO C3 images by amateur astronomer Jiangao Ruan. The comet brightened nicely and was also visible in GOES-19/CCOR-1, SOHO/LASCO C2, STEREO/SECCHI COR2-A and HI1-A images. However, what made this comet stand out (compared to most) was the that it appeared to coincide with a planetary parade, plus a nice CME, and a proton storm! Unfortunately the proton-storm started just after I cut off the animation below (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1: Animation of SOHO/LASCO C3 images showing a moderately-bright Kreutz-group sungrazer among a planetary parade (planets from left-right: Venus, Mercury, Mars), plus a CME! Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO/LASCO C3.

A New SWAN Comet!

On January 22nd, comet hunter Hanjie Tan reported a previously unknown comet in SOHO/SWAN images (Fig. 2), moving rapidly northward as it exited the from behind the “SWAN Solar Occulter”. Although SWAN is not a coronagraph in the same sense as LASCO, it is still capable of observing objects at relatively low solar elongations. The comet was later recovered in data from NASA’s PUNCH mission and in STEREO/SECCHI HI2-A imagery, but it was never detected by ground-based telescopes. By mid-February, the comet had faded quickly and is believed to have disintegrated. This is not surprising as it is likely to have passed quite close to the Sun at perihelion (q~0.3 AU based on preliminary estimations by Sam Deen). Despite the comet having been widely observed by multiple telescopes, it has not (yet) received an official designation. It’s inofficially referred to as SWAN26B.

Fig. 2: Animation of SOHO/SWAN Comet Tracker images showing comet SWAN26B (marked by crosshairs) moving northward (Jan 12 – 31). A brighter comet, C/2024 E1 (Wierzchoś), is also visible moving southward, both receding from SWAN’s solar occulter. Image credit: ESA/NASA/LATMOS SOHO/SWAN.

A “Bright” Meyer-Group Comet

Following the Kreutz-group, the Meyer-group is the most populous known family of comets. A relatively bright member of this group was found recently by Zhijian Xu, a long-time member of the Sungrazer Citizen Science project. The comet was initially discovered in CCOR-1 data, but later briefly passed through the SOHO/LASCO C2 FOV (Fig. 3). Like all Meyer-group comets, this newly-observed member had a highly condensed appearance, showing no evidence of a coma or tail. Other than the limited resolution of CCOR-1 and LASCO, their appearance likely reflects the highly evovled and dynamically inactive nature of these comets.

Fig. 3: Animation showing Zhijian Xu’s recent CCOR-1 Meyer-group comet transiting the SOHO/LASCO C2 FOV. The elongated appearance is likely an artefact rather than instrinsic to the comet, likely resulting from the LASCO telescope. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO/LASCO C2

A Persistent Non-group Comet

On March 20th amateur astronomer Mikolaj Kaszczyk uncovered a faint “new” non-group comet in CCOR-1 images. It was seen slowly moving northward, and was also later recovered in LASCO C3 images. Like the majority of CCOR-1 comet hunters, Mikolaj processes the raw spacecraft data himself. The results for his discovery can be found in Fig. 4. In these images the comet appears stellar, typical of many non-group near-Sun comets, even after stacking. The lack of a resolvable tail or coma is most likely a result of the the telerscope’s moderate resolution and limiting magnitude. As I write this blog post, the comet continues to be present in the CCOR-1 FOV, with a magnitude of +9.8 according to Mikolaj.

Fig. 4: Stacked image showing a small slow-moving non-group comet currently transiting the CCOR-1 FOV. Image credit: NOAA GOES-19/CCOR-1; © Mikolaj Kaszczyk

An Upcoming Great Comet?

Although not yet in daytime skies, comet C/2026 A1 (MAPS) is rapidly approaching perihelion. C/2026 A1 is a rare case of a Kreutz-group comet having been discovered prior to entering the FOV of solar corongraphs, strongly suggesting that it is intrinsically brighter than the “typical” population of coronagraph-detected Kreutz comets (e.g. the one discussed earlier). In fact, C/2026 A1 (MAPS) has already started to surpass +10th magnitude weeks before perihelion! The comet is being followed closely by amateur and professional astronomers alike, with many pretty images available online (e.g. Fig. 5). While some believe C/2016 A1 has the potential of becoming the next “Great comet” (or at least a naked-eye object), it’s important to remain cautious.

Fig. 5: Composite image by astrophotographer Dan Bartlett showing C/2026 A1 (MAPS) from March 9-13, illustrating its rapid inward motion toward perihelion. © Dan Bartlett

Predicting the brightness of sungrazing comets is notoriously difficult, as the past 15 years have shown. While solar radiation drives their activity and brightness, it can ultimately be the cause of their demise. While many historically bright comets have been sungrazers, many near-Sun comets have ultimately disintegrated near perihelion. While C/2011 W3 (Lovejoy) proved to be a spectacular object (despite eventually disintegrating), later potentially “promising” candidates such as C/2012 E2 (SWAN) and C/2024 S1 (ATLAS) were ultimately disappointing, fading into nothing more than objects comparable to SOHO/STEREO-discoveries. Could C/2026 A1 have a similar fate? Personally, I believe there’s a better chance of it becoming brighter (whether it survives or not), especially considering the comet’s brightening trend. Indeed, so far, it appears to act more like a “medium-bright” Kreutz-group fragment rather than C/2024 S1 (Fig. 6).

Fig. 6: Lightcurves of different Kreutz-group sungrazers according to their distance from the Sun. The top figure compares the values of C/2026 A1 with historical great comets, plus the more recent C/2011 W3 and C/2024 S1 (extracted from the website of Nicolas Lefaudeux).

To further compare C/2026 A1 with C/2012 E2, I have created an animation of SWAN images (Fig. 7). The images seem to show that C/2026 A1 appears to be brighter than C/2012 E2 was at this stage of its orbit. It also appears to be brightening much more progressively compared to C/2012 E2, the latter of which which rapidly “switched-on” in SWAN. Note though that it may be that C/2012 E2 suffered an outburst when present in SWAN (Ye et al., 2014). Hence, like for C/2024 S1, I believe that these data support C/2026 A1 being a larger Kreutz fragment than C/2012 E1.

Fig. 7: Animation of SWAN images showing comet C/2012 E2 and C/2026 A1. It seems that these images suggest that C/2026 A1 as brigthening more progressively, and being brighter, than C/2012 E2, in my opinion. Apologies the low for resolution. Image credit: ESA/NASA/LATMOS SOHO/SWAN.

Fortunately, direct observations of the comet’s nucleus were succesfully obtained by the James Webb Space Telescope (Zhang et al., 2026), indicating a diameter of about 400 meters. This is comparable to lower-end estimates for C/2011 W3 (Lovejoy) (400-600 m) and within the range proposed for C/2024 S1 (<600 m) (Jewitt et al., 2025), though those values rely on indirect methods, unlike the direct JWST measurement. Given its similar estimated size to C/2011 W3 and the observed brightening trend, while exluding the more uncertain estimates for C/2024 S1, I suspect C/2026 A1 belongs to the class of Kreutz-group comets that almost-or-barely survive perihelion. Other than C/2011 W3, this includes the “headless wonder” C/1887 B1 (Fig. 8) and C/1945 X1 (Du Toit), which Sekanina (2002) suggested represented a “transitional” population between Great Kreutz comets and the coronagraph-discovered comets.

Fig. 8: The path and evolution of C/1887 B1 as seen in the southern skies. Its appearance shares many similarities to C/2011 W3 (Lovejoy), which was likely of comparable size. Image credit: Possibly Richard Anthony Proctor – Knowledge magazine, November 1, 1887, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=178708006

Although not classified as such by Sekanina (2002), C/1979 Q1 (SOLWIND) may also broadly fit within this category. It was significantly brighter than most coronagraph-discovered Kreutz comets, reaching V = -3 to -4 mag, comparable to C/2011 W3 (Lovejoy) (Fig. 9), and despite not surviving perihelion, produced a distinctive “coronal brightening” not seen in other such objects (Sekanina, 2002). By contrast, C/2012 E2 and C/2024 S1 were significantly fainter, reaching at most about V = 0 mag.

Fig. 9: Corongraphic observations of C/2011 W3 (top-left), C/1979 Q1 (top-right), C/2012 E2 (bottom-left) and C/2024 S1 (bottom-right). Both W3 and Q1 likely represent a larger population of sungrazers than E2 and S1, in my opinion. Image credit: NASA/SSC STEREO/SECCHI COR2-A/B; U.S. Naval Research Laboratory P-78.

Conclusion

The near-Sun environment is a highly dynamic region where comets are frequently observed. Notable examples include those mentioned above, though SWAN26B was discovered at a comparatively larger heliocentric distance. Based on my personal assessment of the current data, I believe C/2026 A1 will likely outshine C/2024 S1 and C/2012 E2, potentially reaching brightness levels comparable to C/1979 Q1, C/1887 B1, or C/2011 W3. Regardless of whether it survives perihelion, it should likely provide an impressive display in space-based coronagraph observations (although not easily visible in daylight from Earth). It is still too early to determine whether it will eventually become spectacular enough to qualify as a “Great comet”.

References

Jewitt, D., Luu, J., & Li, J. (2025). Demise of Kreutz Sungrazing Comet C/2024 S1 (ATLAS). The Astronomical Journal, 169(2), 105.

Sekanina, Z. (2002). Statistical investigation and modeling of sungrazing comets discovered with the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory. The Astrophysical Journal, 566(1), 577-598.

Ye, Q. Z., Hui, M. T., Kracht, R., & Wiegert, P. A. (2014). Where are the mini Kreutz-family comets?. The Astrophysical Journal, 796(2), 83.

Zhang, Q., Knight, M. M., Ye, Q., Schmidt, C. A., & Battams, K. (2026). Preliminary Nucleus Size Estimate for Kreutz Sungrazer C/2026 A1 (MAPS). Research Notes of the AAS, 10(3), 57.

The Comet-mailing list io group, Nicolas Lefaudeux’s website, and the Sungrazer Project website were further used as sources of information.

A Bright New Comet Discovered in SOHO/SWAN Images!

While comets such as 3I/ATLAS and C/2025 A6 (Lemmon) have currently been our main focus, it turned out that another interesting object — magnitude +7 — was quietly lurking in daylight! Provisionally designated SWAN25B, it was discovered by prolific comet hunter Vladimir Bezugly in publicly available data from the SOHO/SWAN instrument. The comet is now on its post-perihelion path, heading into increasingly favorable skies. Current predictions suggest a possible close approach of ~0.25 AU from Earth in mid/late-October. Unfortunately, the comet’s fate remains uncertain, and it may be at risk of disintegration. Regardless, this awesome discovery highlights how fairly bright comets can still slip past modern surveys, especially when they lie at low solar elongations.

Fig. 1: This image of SWAN25B was taken a couple days after its discovery, showing a distinct green coma and a developing ion tail. (c) Michael Jäger and Gerald Rehmann

The Discovery (SWAN) and Confirmation Observations

On September 11th, amateur astronomer Vladimir Bezugly (Dnepropetrovsk, Ukraine) noticed a rather obvious “blob” in the Ultraviolet SWAN comet tracker images, slowly moving away from the Sun in the eastward direction close to the ecliptic (Fig. 2). The earliest SWAN observations of SWAN25B likely date back to August 9th [1]. In the animation below the Sun is “hidden” by an occulting mask, i.e. the “dark grid” in the images.

Fig. 2. Cropped animation from SOHO/SWAN showing the SWAN25B as it brightens and slowly increases in solar elongation. The sequence covers August 7 to September 8, 2025, and includes the discovery observations. Image credit: ESA/NASA/LATMOS SOHO/SWAN.

Despite the low resolution of these images (~1°/pixel), the instrument continues to be a valuable source of comet discoveries, particularly because it can observe regions of the sky at relatively low solar elongations, down to just a few tens of degrees. These are blindspots for modern small body surveys. Moreover, the instrument images the sky at ultraviolet (UV) wavelengths specific to emissions produced from photodissociation of water in the comae of comets by UV solar radiation (i.e. the Lyman-α line: e.g. [2]). Although, despite the instrument’s sensitivity to cometary comae, comets fainter than mag~+12 tend to be too faint for SWAN [1]. Below are further examples of comets (co)discovered by Vladimir in SWAN (Fig. 3).

Fig. 3. Composite image with various comets (co)discovered by Vladimir as seen in SWAN around discovery. Note how each comet is at relatively low solar elongation. Image credit: ESA/NASA/LATMOS SOHO/SWAN.

However, as nice as the SWAN images are for discovering comets, ground-based observations are often required for confirmation. For this, Vladimir reached out to Martin Mašek (of the Institute of Physics of Czech academy of sciences) for confirmation observations. These were obtained on September 12th via the robotic FRAM instrument near Cerro Paranal in Chile. As stated by Martin on the Comet Mailing list: “I was very pleasantly surprised by such a bright comet with a long tail — I originally expected to be searching for a small, faint patch.” [1]. Indeed, as Vladimir also wrote: “[From] my memory this comet is one of the brightest among of all comets that we have ever discovered in the SWAN images” [1].

Fig. 4: Ground-based confirmation image of SWAN25B as captured by Martin Mašek, showing a bright head and a spectacular 2.8° tail. (c) Martin Mašek/Institute of Physics of Czech academy of sciences

Orbit Determination and Future Expectations

The currently short observation arc, plus the low resolution of the SWAN images, make the determination of a “accurate” orbit relatively difficult. As previously mentioned, the earliest observations from the SWAN instrument date back to early/mid-August, with ground-based observations being only very recent. However, fortunately, the comet was recovered in images from the STEREO-A HI1 imager during August-September (Fig. 5). These images are of higher resolution than the SWAN comet tracker map images, thus allowing for more precise astrometry.

Fig. 5: Cropped STEREO-A HI1 images showing the tail dynamics of SWAN25B over the course of September 4th to 6th, 2025. Image credit/ NASA/SSC STEREO/SECCHI HI1-A difference images.

A preliminary solution calculated by Sam Deen indicates a perihelion distance of only 0.5 AU on September 12th, and a relatively close approach (0.25 AU) with Earth in October! Furthermore, Sam predicts that the Earth will pass through the comet’s meteor stream in early October: ”In any case Earth will cross through its meteor stream shortly before the comet, around October 4th-6th when there’s a slim chance a low-level meteor shower outburst will occur due to how close it is to the comet’s encounter, albeit ahead of the comet in its orbit rather than behind.” [1]

Due to the bright nature of SWAN25B, comet experts such as Michael Mattiazzo have suggested that it might be undergoing an outburst [1]. If this is the case, the comet is likely to become significantly fainter in the near future as it returns to its quiscent state. Outbursts, particularly near perihelion, are not particularly uncommon in comets. However, there is also the possibility of the comet fading from disintegration. Indeed, images from Jost Jahn (Fig. 6) possibly indicate a “triangular” coma. This is commonly observed in “outbursting comets” just before they disintegrate, a famous example being C/1996 Q1 (Tabur). For now though, little is known about SWAN25B, but it’s presumed that it will most likely fade, despite the approach. Regardless, predicting the brightness of comets is very difficult, even for those we know well.

Fig. 6: Image captured of SWAN25B by Jost Jahn showing what may be a somewhat ”triangular” coma. These tend to be a warning sign that the comet is in the process of falling apart. (c) Jost Jahn.

The comet is currently passing between Spica and Mars, appearing especially close to Spica. Its closest apparent approach to the star will occur on September 15–16th [3]. Michael Mattiazzo has captured this encounter beautifully in the image below (Fig. 7). Moreover, the comet will remain present in the STEREO/SECCHI HI1 and HI2 FOV for next several weeks, although it will likely fade as it moves away from the spacecraft and perihelion.

Fig. 7: Picture showing SWAN25B approaching Spica (bright blue star). The tail is over 2° long based on this image. (c) Michael Mattiazzo.

Acknoweldgements

I would like to thank Gerald Rehmann, Jost Jahn, Martin Mašek, Michael Jäger and Michael Mattiazzo for kindly granting permission to use their images in this blog post. A thanks to my partner for his input, as well!

References

[1] Comets Mailing List comets-ml@groups.io (September, 2025, entries): https://groups.io/g/comets-ml

[2] Combi, M. R., Mäkinen, T., Bertaux, J. L., Quémerais, E., & Ferron, S. (2025). Water production rates from SOHO/SWAN observations of Comets C/2017 K2 (PanSTARRS) and C/2022 E3 (ZTF). Icarus, 116645.

[3] https://earthsky.org/space/new-comet-swan25b-2025/ (Accessed 14/09/2025).

This blog post also makes use of data from the ESA/NASA/LATMOS SOHO/SWAN and NASA STEREO/SECCHI HI1-A instruments.

Amateur Astronomers are Discovering Comets in Online Data from the GOES-19 Satellite!

After only two months of making their data publicly accessible, almost thirty previously-unknown sungrazing comets have been identified in images obtained by the GOES-19 satellite! All these comets were found by a handful of amateur astronomers diligently analyzing the preliminary “non-operational” CCOR-1 data being posted in real time. With the rapid increase in “CCOR comets” so early in the satellite’s mission, it is possible that CCOR-1 may become a prolific comet discoverer!

Fig. 1: Composite image of four comets discovered in CCOR-1 images from the GOES-19 satellite. The white circles outline the solar disk. Image credit: Preliminary non-operational data from NOAA GOES-19/CCOR-1.

The Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellites (GOES) are a collaborative program between the NOAA and NASA that aims to survey both Earth and space weather. The GOES-19 satellite (initially named GOES-U) was launched on June 24th, 2024, and is the most recent satellite of this program. Among the instruments that it carries are the Compact CORongraph (CCOR) 1 and 2, which track the Sun’s activity in real time by continuously imaging its corona. This is done by blocking the Sun’s overwhelming glare via an occulting disk, making it possible to observe the much fainter surrounding solar corona (including coronal mass ejections: Fig. 2). This is important as the Sun can strongly interfer with electronics aboard satellites, but also on Earth.

Fig. 2: A coronal mass ejection captured by CCOR-1 on February 24th, 2025. Each image was taken with a 15-minute interval. The white circle is the outline of the solar disk. Image credit: Preliminary non-operational data from NOAA GOES-19/CCOR-1.

However, a bonus of blocking the Sun’s intense glare is the ability of observing its immediate environment, most notably sungrazing comets. Considering that most “sungrazers” are intrinsically faint and only “flare up” near perihelion, they go undetected by traditional minor planet surveys. Moreover, as most sungrazers are part of dynamically (and rapidly) evolving comet families, they are very abundant, making coronagraphs the leading source of comet discoveries. In fact, ESA/NASA’s SOHO/LASCO coronagraphs observe multiple sungrazers weekly and have discovered more than 5000 comets. Most, however, are tiny (metric-decametric-sized) members of the vast Kreutz-group comet family. Examples of “typical” sungrazers observed by SOHO/LASCO are shown in Fig. 3.

Fig. 3: Multiple examples of tiny Kreutz-group comet fragments as captured by the SOHO/LASCO C2 coronagraph. Noise was manually removed by the author. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO/LASCO C2.

Moreover, as a lot of data from coronagraphs are made accessible online, nearly all sungrazers are found by amateur scientists from the comfort of their own homes. The CCOR data is no exception. Indeed, since real time data was made public in early February, almost thirty sungrazers have been identified by a handful of amateurs via the Sungrazer Citizen Science Project (Fig. 4).

Fig. 4: Screenshot of the Sungrazer Project homepage, a citizen science project which makes it possible for amateur astronomers to report comets in images from space-based coronagraphs, including GOES-19/CCOR.

Among them, Robert Pickard was the first to find a new comet in CCOR: “I started looking on February 6th right after I saw on Facebook that the data is out in the form of a GIF. […] I was checking real time CCOR-1 jpeg images on February 11th. It was early evening (still February 10th where I live). [On an image taken at] 00:15UT I noted an object at the edge of the field“. Karl Battams (NRL), lead scientist of the Sungrazer Project, rapidly confirmed the find: “I can definitely see this new comet — and I think we can confidently plant the ‘first CCOR-1 discovery’ flag in it“. The comet was later recovered in data from the SOHO/LASCO C3 (Fig. 5) and STEREO/SECCHI HI1-A telescopes.

Fig. 5: Animation of the first “CCOR-1” comet discovery as seen from the SOHO/LASCO telescope. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO/LASCO C3.

In regard to his comet, Robert further states: “It felt great! I really enjoyed finding early success with the new instrument. The instrument is really user-friendly if you know where to look for the comets“. Currently he has found eight sungrazers in CCOR-1 (including Sungrazer #8 in Fig. 1), and a combined total of almost one hundred via the Sungrazer Project. 

Since this first comet, three other prolific sungrazing comet hunters have also contributed to the CCOR comet count: Jiangao Ruan, Worachate Boonplod and Zhijian Xu. For example, Jiangao is currently the leading discoverer CCOR comets, including Sungrazers #12, 13 and 23 in Fig. 1. An animation of #23 in CCOR is presented below (Fig. 6).

Fig. 6: Animation of a Kreutz-group sungrazing comet seen plunging towards the Sun. This comet was found by Jiangao Ruan on March 16th, 2025. Image credit: Preliminary non-operational data from NOAA GOES-19/CCOR-1.

The success of CCOR as a comet hunting tool is due to multiple reasons: (i) The high-quality data is often made more rapidly available than other similar coronographs (e.g. SOHO/LASCO and STEREO/SECCHI). In fact, multiple CCOR comets were later recovered in SOHO/LASCO and STEREO/SECCHI after first being found in CCOR (e.g. Fig. 5); (ii) The CCOR-1 images are of higher resolution than those of the SOHO/LASCO C3 instrument (where most sungrazers are found during February-March), meaning that it can detect smaller comets that otherwise would have gone unnoticed; (iii) The CCOR-1 instrument images in wavelengths between 480-730 nm, which includes the cometary sodium emission lines at 589 nm, making CCOR (like SOHO/LASCO) particularly sensitive to observing comets. This includes those of relatively low activity, such as Meyer-group comets. In fact, until CCOR, all Meyer-group comets had ever only been observed by LASCO. Furthermore, CCOR-1 also observed various Kreutz-group comets discovered by SOHO/LASCO (example: Fig. 7).

Fig. 7: An example of a SOHO-discovered Kreutz-group comet captured by the CCOR-1 coronagraph on February 25th, 2025. Image credit: Preliminary non-operational data from NOAA GOES-19/CCOR-1.

Currently, the available CCOR-1 data is considered preliminary. The “operational” data will be acquired as of April 4th, 2025. These data will likely be of higher quality than the currently available images, perhaps further boosting the number of future CCOR comet discoveries. Consequently, with the SOHO spacecraft soon retirering, GOES-19 will be a suiteable replacement, both as a coronagraph and comet hunter!

Acknowledgements: I wish to thank Robert Pickard for the information that he provided regarding his experience with CCOR comet hunting. Images used in the making of this post are/were publicly available via the CCOR-1 website and the SOHO Movie Theater.

Szabo Bluff 12432: Could it be a Severely Heated CM Chondrite?

Szabo Bluff (SZA) 12432 is a carbonaceous chondrite (CC) of relatively large mass (163 g), previously considered paired with another CC, SZA 12431 (443 g). Although both meteorites were initially considered as Ornans-type (CO) chondrites, recent bulk Oxygen (O-)isotopic analysis suggest that they stem from seperate meteoroids, with SZA 12431 being a Mighei-type (CM) chondrite. Although SZA 12432 has remained classified as a CO, I wonder whether it may be more closely related to certain primitive Mighei-type (CM) chondrites, such as Lewis Cliff (LEW) 85311 or Reckling Peak (RKP) 17085. Furthermore, online images suggest the presence of widespread dessication cracks, possibly indicative of aqueous alteration prior to (a) severe heating event(s). If this is correct, then it may be possible that the meteorite was once a fragment from the surface of a primitive Near-Sun C-complex asteroid.

Fig. 1: Image of SZA 12432 with a ruler for scale. The rock is covered in “whitish” minerals, most likely evaporites from terrestrial weathering. Image credit: the Antarctic Meteorite Newletter (AMN).

Mineralogy and petrography: SZA 12432 has many similarities with “typical” CO chondrites, including: (i) an olivine-rich matrix, (ii) small chondrules, (iii) plus the presence of Calcium Aluminium-rich Inclusions (CAIs) (see description in the MBDB). However, these characteristics are also consistent with heated CM chondrites, such as Pecora Escarpment (PCA 91008). To understand whether SZA 12342 is more closely related to CO or CM chondrites, we can look at its matrix abundance, as the matrix/chondrule ratio in CMs is superior to 1, with the contrary being the case for COs. A look at the available images online suggest that SZA 12342 may indeed be more matrix-rich than typically observed in COs (Fig. 1).

Fig. 2: Image comparison (plane-polarized light) between SZA 12432 and Miller Range 07417 (the latter a typical CO3 chondrite). The dark regions correspond the the meteorite’s matrix, while the colorful inclusions correspond to chondrules, and refractory inclusions (including CAIs). This image comparison suggests that SZA 12432 is significantly more matrix-rich than a typical CO. Image credit: the Antarctic Meteorite Newletter (AMN).

Moreover, the texture of this meteorite is very similar to PCA 91008, showing abundant fractures (likely dessication cracks), which I interpret as being the result of dehydroxylation of phyllosilicates through (a) heating event(s) (based on Mouti Al‐Hashimi et al., 2024). Personally, I rarely see this in CO chondrites, probably as they rarely appear to have been hydrated (although there may be exceptions). However, the extent of aqueous alteration was possibly quite mild, considering the presence of metal in the meteorite’s matrix (MBDB). Matrix metal in CMs is generally observed in the least altered CMs (e.g. A-12136, LEW 85311: Lee et al., 2019; Kimura et al., 2020). Although, alternatively, matrix metal can also result from the recrystallization of magnetite through severe heating (e.g; King et al., 2021).

Fig. 3: Image comparison (reflected light) between SZA 12432 and PCA 91008 (the latter being a severely heated chondrite). Both meteorites are texturally similar, particularly by the presence of an extensive network of dessication cracks from the a heating event. This implies both meteorites likely contained hydrated silicates the past, a feature typical of CMs. Image credit: the Antarctic Meteorite Newletter (AMN).

Bulk O-isotopic measurements: At first glance, the published values in the Meteoritical Bulletin are consistent with SZA 12432 being a CO3 chondrite (Fig. 4). However, its composition does not overlap with other Antarctic CO chondrites, despite its severely weathered nature (grade Ce).

Fig. 4: Three oxygen plot showing the bulk O-isotopic composition of COs and CMs, with an emphasis SZA 12431 and 12432. That of the latter does not plot with Antarctic COs (most of which are circled in black). Abbreviations: MIL 09: MIL 090785; MIL07: MIL07687; LEW: 85311; EET: EET 96029; PCA: PCA 91008 (review value); JW: Jbilet Winselwan; CM3.0 (A-12136); NWA: NWA 5958; RKP: RKP 17085.

Indeed, with Antarctic weathering (and considering that the sample has not been “leached”), we expect a shift in the O-isotopic composition towards Standard Light Antarctic Precipitation (SLAP) values (Greenwood et al., 2018). If the samples were “raw”, then it should rather be compared to with LEW 85311 and RKP 17085. I expect that the “unweathered” composition of SZA 12432 (plus RKP 17085 and LEW 85311) may have plotted near most “primitive CM” chondrites (Fig. 2). This may be consistent with the presence of intact metal in the meteorite’s matrix (MBDB), a trait common in primitive* CMs (see above). I suspect, based on the above information, that RKP 17085 may be most analogous to RKP 17085.

Implications: The fact that SZA 12342 could be a mild aqueously altered CM in itself is already interesting, despite having been thermally metamorphosed. This is similar to the case of multiple primitive CMs, including EET 96029, Paris, and the previously-mentioned RKP 17085, all of which have been post-aqueously heated (Lee et al., 2016; Marrocchi et al., 2014; Mussolino et al., 2024). By extension, as suggested for EET 96029, it may be analogous to the surface of a (once-)primitive C-complex asteroid (Lee et al., 2016). However, unlike the aformentioned CMs, the temperatures experienced by SZA 12432 were likely significantly higher (>750°C, versus possibly <750°C). Moreover, considering that dessication cracks could form from recurrent heating during perihelia passages (Mouti Al‐Hashimi et al., 2024), then SZA 12432 may have stem from a Near Earth Object with a relatively low perihelion distance (q). Indeed, to reach such high temperatures, q must have been very low (below 0.25 AU, where surface temperatures reach t>800K: Jewitt, 2013). As such, I wonder whether SZA 12432 may have been a Near-Sun Object, potentially being a similar case to (3200) Phaethon (Fig.5). Noble gas spectrophotometry may be useful to verify whether SZA 12432 was, at some point, exposed on the surface of its parent asteroid (see Krietch et al., 2021).

Fig. 5: Annotated STEREO HI1-A image showing asteroid (3200) Phaethon only days prior from its 2012 perihelion passage. Image credit: NASA/NRL STEREO/SECCHI HI1-A.

In fact, (3200) Phaethon has been associated to the Yamato-type (CY) chondrites, which might have a similar thermal history to mild-severely heated CMs: King et al., 2019; Quirico et al., 2018; MacLennan & Granvik, 2024). Considering that CM (and CO) chondrites likely originate from the Asteroid Belt (AB), I expect the of the SZA 12432 Near-Earth Object is located there too, if still present. However, we have yet to rule out that any thermal metamorphism in SZA 12432 was radiogenic or the result of impact heating (e.g. Quirico et al., 2018). Much has yet to be learned about SZA 12432 before any conclusion can be reached, first starting by its classification.

Conclusion: SZA 12432, although currently classified as a CO chondrite, may be a relatively mildly aqueously altered CM chondrite which subsequently experienced significant heating (similarly, although more severely, than RKP 17085). The presence of dessication cracks supports the past presence of hydrated silicates, and may also be evidence of repeated heating during perihelia passages. The severe degree of heating indicates that the meteoroid (or parent Near Earth Object) had a very low q. If indeed a CM chondrite, the low degree of aqueous alteration and/or severe heating is supported by the presence of metal in the meteorite’s matrix. Furthermore, it could also mean that the meteoroid was probably excavated from a C-complex asteroid in the Main Asteroid Belt prior to being thrown into a Near-Earth/Sun orbit, and may have been exposed at the surface. Heating of impact or radiogenic origin cannot be ruled out without further study of the meteorite. Fortunately, the large sample mass of this meteorite might make it relatively available for analysis. One drawback of this meteorite, however, is its severely weathered nature.

References

Jewitt, D. (2013). Properties of near-Sun asteroids. The Astronomical Journal, 145(5), 133.

Greenwood, R. C., Bowden, R., Gibson, J. M., Howard, K. T., & Franchi, I. A. (2018). A mutli-technique search for the most primitive CO chondrites. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 221, 406-420.

King, A. J., Bates, H. C., Krietsch, D., Busemann, H., Clay, P. L., Schofield, P. F., & Russell, S. S. (2019). The Yamato-type (CY) carbonaceous chondrite group: Analogues for the surface of asteroid Ryugu?. Geochemistry, 79(4), 125531.

King, A. J., Schofield, P. F., & Russell, S. S. (2021). Thermal alteration of CM carbonaceous chondrites: mineralogical changes and metamorphic temperatures. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 298, 167-190.

Kimura, M., Imae, N., Komatsu, M., Barrat, J. A., Greenwood, R. C., Yamaguchi, A., & Noguchi, T. (2020). The most primitive CM chondrites, Asuka 12085, 12169, and 12236, of subtypes 3.0–2.8: Their characteristic features and classification. Polar Science, 26, 100565.

Krietsch, D., Busemann, H., Riebe, M. E., King, A. J., Alexander, C. M. D., & Maden, C. (2021). Noble gases in CM carbonaceous chondrites: Effect of parent body aqueous and thermal alteration and cosmic ray exposure ages. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 310, 240-280.

Lee, M. R., Lindgren, P., King, A. J., Greenwood, R. C., Franchi, I. A., & Sparkes, R. (2016). Elephant Moraine 96029, a very mildly aqueously altered and heated CM carbonaceous chondrite: Implications for the drivers of parent body processing. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 187, 237-259.

Lee, M. R., Cohen, B. E., King, A. J., & Greenwood, R. C. (2019). The diversity of CM carbonaceous chondrite parent bodies explored using Lewis Cliff 85311. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 264, 224-244.

MacLennan, E., & Granvik, M. (2024). Thermal decomposition as the activity driver of near-Earth asteroid (3200) Phaethon. Nature Astronomy, 8(1), 60-68.

Marrocchi, Y., Gounelle, M., Blanchard, I., Caste, F., & Kearsley, A. T. (2014). The Paris CM chondrite: Secondary minerals and asteroidal processing. Meteoritics & Planetary Science, 49(7), 1232-1249.

Mouti Al‐Hashimi, X., Davidson, J., Schrader, D. L., & Bullock, E. S. (2024). Fine‐grained chondrule rims in Mighei‐like carbonaceous chondrites: Evidence for a nebular origin and modification by impacts and recurrent solar radiation heating. Meteoritics & Planetary Science, 59(4), 789-808.

Musolino, A., Suttle, M. D., Folco, L., King, A. J., Poggiali, G., Bates, H. C., … & Brearley, A. (2024). Early fluid migration and alteration fronts in the CM chondrite Reckling Peak 17085. Meteoritics & Planetary Science, 59(11), 3021-3043.

Quirico, E., Bonal, L., Beck, P., Yabuta, H., Nakamura, T., Nakato, A., … & Herd, C. D. K. (2018). Prevalence and nature of heating processes in CM and C2-ungrouped chondrites as revealed by insoluble organic matter. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 241, 17-37.

* Primitive = in this case I refer to CMs having experienced a low degree of aqueous alteration. Some, have been post-aqueously heated.

The Story of Comet C/1998 G3 (SOHO), a Relatively Bright Non-group Comet!

Among the 5000 near-sun comets that have been identified in SOHO/LASCO, the vast majority belong to comet families (notably the Kreutz group). This post describes the case of C/1998 G3 (SOHO), a non-group comet that possibly reached a peak brightness of mag +4 or +5. Moreover, it was also sufficiently bright (at least in the UV) to be tracked in SWAN images two weeks prior to perihelion. This is particularly rare for any SOHO comet. Despite this, the comet faded from disintegration and/or observing geometry

Fig. 1: Animation showing the transit of comet C/1998 G3 (SOHO) through the SOHO/LASCO C3 FOV. The comet became quickly elongated after entering the FOV, and then rapidly faded by the end of the animation. Evidence of the comet’s ramining “debris cloud” can be seen moving northward after perihelion. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO/LASCO C3.

C/1998 G3 (SOHO) was a non-group comet identified by Kevin Schenk, a NASA scientist of the SOHO/LASCO team. The comet can be seen entering the SOHO/LASCO C3 FOV on April 10th, 1998 (Fig. 1); rapidly moving southwest before entering the lower right portion of the C2 FOV on April 12th (Fig. 2). After exiting C2 the comet rapidly faded, appearing very diffuse as it moves north. This may have been due to the observing geometry (as implied here) and/or disintegration (consistent with its morphology, see below). Regardless, the comet was easily detectable in SOHO/LASCO before and around perihelion. I roughly estimate a peak magnitude of +4 or +5. This is significantly brighter than most SOHO comets. The brightness was likely enhanced by forward scattering.

Fig. 2: Animation showing the rapid passage of comet C/1998 G3 (SOHO) through the SOHO/LASCO C2 FOV. Note how the comet was already clearly elongated, as it had probably already disintagrated. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO/LASCO C2.

Notice that the comet had an elongated appearance soon after entering the SOHO/LASCO FOV (Fig. 1). This morphology is indicative of a disintegrating comet. In fact, in SOHO/LASCO C2, the object shows no head (Fig. 2). By that time, I suspect it that it had already fallen apart. More specifically, it is likely that the “tail” was a “debris field”, rather cometary activity driven by an active nucleus. This type of feature is very commonly observed in SOHO/LASCO comets (Fig. 3).

Fig. 3: Two examples of SOHO comets with morphologies similar to C/1998 G3 (SOHO): bright elongated “tails” (debril trails). Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO/LASCO C2.

According to the IAU, based on the limited observation arc (1998 04 10.5 – 1998 04 13.6), C/1998 G3 had a perihelion distance of only 0.0354 AU. Additionally, considering the intrinsically small size of the comet, it’s unsurpsing that it failed to survive its solar encounter. Considering its very faint nature, plus the observing geometry, I suspect that it would have been impossible to recover from Earth, (unlike the case of C/2015 D1), even using modern equipment.

Prior to entering the SOHO/LASCO FOV, the comet was visible for over a week in SOHO/SWAN UV “Comet Tracker” images (Fig. 4). This means that observations extend almost two weeks before its perihelion passage. As the SWAN images show, C/1998 G3 can be seen brightening before heading behind the SOHO/SWAN “solar” occulter. Interestingly, it was not listed as having been detected in SWAN by Mäkinnen et al. (2001). I suspect however that these “precovery” observations have been noted more recently. Whether they would be useful to constrain a better orbit is a different question, considering the low resolution of the SWAN images. Please let me know if I have overlooked a reference.

Fig. 4: Comet C/1998 G3 (SOHO) as seen in SOHO/SWAN, between March 27th and April 5th, 1998. Image credit:  Image credit: ESA/NASA/LATMOS SOHO/SWAN.

References

Mäkinen, J. T. T., Bertaux, J. L., Pulkkinen, T. I., Schmidt, W., Kyrölä, E., Summanen, T., … & Lallement, R. (2001). Comets in full sky maps of the SWAN instrument-I. Survey from 1996 to 1998. Astronomy & Astrophysics, 368(1), 292-297.

With the exception of the above sources, this blog post is based on my own examination and interpretations of the publicly available SOHO/LASCO and SOHO/SWAN data:

The Story of Comet C/2015 D1 (SOHO)!

The SOHO/LASCO coronagraph has enabled the discovery of more than five throusand near-sun comet! However most are tiny meter-sized sungrazers that quickly fall apart just before perihelion. As such, they are almost never recovered from Earth. There are however exceptions, as was the case of C/2015 D1 (SOHO)! Indeed, although the comet ultimately fell apart, it made it passed perihelion and could be tracked over over a week as it moved into darker skies. In fact, beautiful images were obtained of the remaining dust cloud before it faded and dissipated beyond detection.

output_3pkOoY

Fig. 1: Animation of comet C/2015 D1 (SOHO) during its transit across SOHO/LASCO C3 images. Note that at the beginning of the animation the comet appears rather condensed, while it appears significantly more elongated as it exits the FOV. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO/LASCO C3.

C/2015 D1 (SOHO) was a relatively bright non-group comet found by Worachate Boonplod (Thailand) in SOHO/LASCO C3 images of February 18th, 2015. When discovered, the comet was near the (northern) edge of the C3 FOV, shining faintly at around mag +10, and brightening (Fig. 1). Hence, it was clear that the comet would probably become a relatively bright object. Indeed, over the course of the next 24 hours, the comet brightened considerably, shining at around mag +5 by the late hours of February 19th. In regards to its morphology, it displayed a condensed appearance with a very faint tail. Many expected the comet to disintegrate, as is the fate of most SOHO comets.

As the comet entered the C2 FOV, it remained condensed, still displaying a faint tail opposite its [rapid] motion. However, rather than fading, it rapidly brightened as it cruised past perihelion. In fact, the comet’s brightness saturated the C2 imager (Fig. 2), suggesting that it had probably reached mag +2. It hds also developed a faint (curved) tail that was progressively seen growing (possibly, in part, due to the angle of observation).C2015D1_C2_SatFig. 2: SOHO/LASCO C2 image extract showing C/2015 D1 (SOHO) on February 19th, 2015, only an hour before it left the FOV. Notice the saturation spikes, indicative that the comet probably reached was shining around mag +2 in this image. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO/LASCO C2.

During this period, the comet had also picked-up in two images by the STEREO/SECCHI COR2-A telescope (see Fig. 4). Unfortunately, due to the low quality of the images at the time (side-lobe operations), these could not be used to further contribute to establishing better orbital elements.C2015D1_COR2AFig. 3: One of two STEREO/SECCHI COR2-A image showing C/2015 D1 (SOHO). The images were taken during side-lobe operations hence the low resolution of this image. Als note Jupiter to the left of the Sun, and a massive CME. Image credit: NASA/SSC STEREO/SECCHI COR2-A.

The comet faded slowly, and left C3 on February 21st, 2015.  At first glance, it seemed relatively “healthy”, although it was noted that it did appear slightly more elongated (Battams et al., 2015). Amazingly, it only took four days before ground-based instruments caught this small comet. The first to recover it was Justin Coward (USA) using where they noticed that it appeared only as a faint elongate “smudge”, clearly indicating that the comet had fully disintegrated inbetween the time it left SOHO/LASCO. As a consequence of its disintegration, the comet was not recovered in SOHO/SWAN.

Justin_Cowart_Recovery_C2015D1_SOHOFig. 4: Extract of Justin Cowart’s recovery image of C/2015 D1 (SOHO). This was the first ground-based image of the comet. (c) Justin Cowart.

The remaining cloud that was once comet SOHO kept dissipating and fading, as is seen when comparing Michael Jäger’s images from February 28th and March 7th, 2015 (Fig. 5 and 6). The fact that this comet quickly fell apart is indicative of C/2015 D1 being an intrinsically faint comet, much like nearly all near-sun comets.

Fig. 5: Detailed color image of comet C/2015 D1 (SOHO) as imaged February 28th, 2015. (C) Michael Jäger.
Fig. 6: Detailed color image of comet C/2015 D1 (SOHO) taken on March 7th, 2015. (c) Michael Jäger.

Identifying Modestly Altered and Possibly Anomalous CMs from the Yamato Glacier!

Mighei-type (CM) chondrites make up the majority of carbonaceous chondrites in our collections, with many having been found at the Yamato Glacier in Antarctica. However, the extent of alteration has only been assessed in a fraction of all CMs. With the use of publicly available spectra from the RELAB database, I’ve tried to evaluate the cases of Y-791191, Y-793602 and Y-791824, all three of which have not been attributed petrologic grades in recent litterature. It seems possible that Y-791191 and 793601 are similarly altered to Y-791198 (a modestly altered CM). I suspect that they might be paired. On the other hand, Y-791824 is severely altered and has also experienced a peculiar style of terrestrial weathering, apparently distinct from (most?) other CMs (i.e. abundant Ca-sulfates). As such, it may not be a “typical” CM.

Mid-Infrared spectroscopy is useful at estimating the degree of aqueous alteration in CM chondrites. More specifically, it allows to study the relative abundance and Mg/Fe composition of phyllosilicate minerals, both which increase with alteration. In each case, they represent the progressive replacement of Mg-rich anhydrous silicate phenocryst with phyllosilicates. More specifically, phyllosilicates are firstly developped in the Fe-rich fine-grained matrix, which then increase in Mg from corrosion of the fosterite and enstatite in chondrules and chondrule fragments. Fig. 1 shows an example of CM phyllosilicates seen through Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) (By Chizmadia & Brearley, 2008).

Fig. 1: TEM image of Y-791198 showing serpentine lattice fringes. Those present to the left are of significantly lower crystallographic order, compared to those of the right. Image extracted from Chizmadia & Brearley (2008).

In the least altered CMs, nucleation of phyllosilicates may have been arrested early-on due to limited hydrothermal alteration. This has been reported in very few CMs, including Yamato (Y)-791198 (Chizmadia & Brearley, 2008). Such meteorites are interesting as they preserve “primary” phases that are particularly susceptible to alteration, notably amorphous nebular condensates (Fig. 2). Considering the large number of CMs discovered at the Yamoto glacier, it begs the question of whether there may be additional samples similar to Y-791198 (paired to this meteorite or not).

Fig. 2: TEM observations of Y-791198 showing primitive amorphous material. These amorphous “silicate” phases are rapidly replaced by phyllosilicates with aqueous alteration, indicating that alterationwas incipient, at best, in the above sections studied by TEM. Image extracted from: Chizmadia & Brearley (2008).

In addition to being the source of a mildly-altered CM chondrite, many “Yamato CMs” (and “CIs”) have turned out to be members of another meteorite group in its namesake: the Yamato-group, a.k.a. the “CYs” (Ikeda, 1992; King et al., 2019). With the help of spectroscopy, I wonder whether it may be possible to identify other unusual samples that are misclassified as CMs. Such meteorites may be possible to distiguish from “typical” CMs on the basis of mineral signatures that are atypical of this meteorite group.

Two answer the above questions, I looked into spectra of meteorite fragments from the RELAB database: Y-791191(-95), Y-793601(-95) and Y-791824(-84). To my knowledge, these meteorites lack petrological classification using modern classification schemes (see Table 1). I compare their Mid-Infrared reflectance spectra with Y-791198 and various other CMs having been referred petrologic grades in the litterature (Table 1): Murchison, Nogoya, LAP 04796(-9) and ALH, 84044(-25). I also briefly rediscuss the degree of aqueous alteration of Y-791198-101, as it has been considered mildly altered in some studies (Chizmadia & Brearley, 2008), and more in others (e.g. Rubin et al., 2007). This discussion includes parts of a discussion that I made in a previous blog post.

The “3-micron” Absorption Band (Fe/Mg-Phyllosilicate content)

Phyllosilicate minerals show strong absorption features close to 3 microns, as a result of their hydroxyl (-OH) radicals (Fig. 3). More specifically, the absorption are due to the stretching mode of X-OH, where “X” represents a transition metal (in this case, Fe or Mg). The position of this band shifts from 2.82 to 2.72 microns with increasing Mg/Fe ratio, i.e. aqueous alteration. Moreover, the 3-micron band also becomes progressively narrower with increasing Mg/Fe ratio. Overlapping water and oxyhydroxides tend to also present at slightly larger (2.95 micron) wavelengths. Note that some meteorites (i.e. Murchison) show both Fe-rich and Mg-rich phyllosilicate signatures.

Fig. 3: Collection of various CM chondrite reflectance spectra from the RELAB database (window: 2.5 – 4.0 microns), including the four subjects of this blog post: Y-791191, 793601, and 791824. All the samples were in the form of “chips”, i.e. uncrushed fragments. Raw data extracted from the RELAB database.

Visually, based on Fig. 1, the overall Fe/Mg content in the CMs should aproximately vary in the following order: LAP 04796, Y-791191 < Y-791198, Y-793601 (predominantely Fe-rich phyllosilicates) < Murchison < Y-791824 < Nogoya, ALH 84044. Y-791824, like Murchison, contain both Fe and Mg-rich phyllosilicate signatures, although the Mg-rich band is more prominent in the former than the latter.

The 13 – 25-micron region (Hydrous-vs-Anhydrous silicates)

This spectral window is dominated by the contribution of Mg-rich silicates, particularly as Si-O bending vibrations, as well as Mg-OH bonds in phyllosilicates (Fig. 4). This region can distinguishing the contribution of Mg-rich anhydrous and hydrated silicates, and is thus useful at studying the degree of aqueous alteration. In Fig. 3, we see that the hydrous-vs-anhydrous signature intensities decrease in the following order: LAP 04796 > Y-793601 > Y-791191, Y-791198 > Murchison > Y-791824, Nogoya ≥ ALH 84044.

Fig. 4: Collection of various CM chondrite reflectance spectra from the RELAB database (window: 13 – 25 microns), including the four subjects of this blog post: Y-791191, 793601, and 791824. The dark lines represent signatures of anhydrous silicates, notably olivine and enstatite. All the samples were in the form of “chips”, i.e. uncrushed fragments. Raw data extracted from the RELAB database.

Degree of Aqueous Alteration and Primary Classification

Considering the notable spectroscopic similarities between Y-791191, 793601 and 791198, I suspect that they may all be paired. However, without further analysis, I cannot confirm this. Among the meteorites in Fig. 3 and 4, these three CMs are spectroscopically similar to LAP 04796, a CM2.6 (King et al., 2020), albeit slightly more altered. They are significantly less altered than Murchison, a CM2.5 (Rubin et al., 2007). As such, I estimate Y-791198-101 (and by extent, Y-791191 and 793601) as being CM2.5/2.6 (I also discuss this spectrum in my previous blog post).

Kojima+(1984)Rubin+(2007)Alexander+(2013)
Y-791191
Y-791824
Y-791824III/IV
Y-791198II2.4
LAP 047962.6*
Murchison2.51.6
Nogoya2.2
ALH 840441.2
Table 1: Petrologic grades of different CMs, through different scales, according to the litterature. Excluding the Yamato samples, the values suggest the following increasing degree of aqueous alteration: LAP 04796 < Murchison < Nogoya < ALH 84044. *From King et al. (2019). No estimations have been made for Y-791191 and Y-791824, to my knowledge.

However, the latter is assuming that the Murchison fragment is comparably altered to the section studied by Rubin et al. (2007), which might not be the case. I suspect, however, that the degree of aqueous alteration of Y-791191, 793601 and 791198 is relatively modest, and possibly less so than reported in Rubin et al. (2007).

In regards to the primary amorphous phases reported in Y-791198, these have also been identified in LAP 04796 (see King et al., 2020, from memory). However, despite this, the meteorite predominantly consists of serpentine (King et al., 2020). By extension, this could mean that the amorphous-rich regions studied by Chizmadia & Brearley (2008) are unrepresentative of the meteorite. Indeed, note that their study was limited to TEM observations of the Fine-grained Rims, rather than larger sections that may be representative of the “bulk” meteorite.

Lastly, CM chondrites are breccia, commonly made-up of lithologies having experienced different degrees of aqueous alteration (e.g. Suttle et al., 2022). Regardless, the spectra point towards Y-791191-95, 793601-95 and 791198-101 being modestly altered CM fragments. Consequently, like for Y-791198, the meteorites Y-791191 and 793601 could potentially host primitive materials that are highly susceptible to alteration. I assume, however, that these materials would be rather localized.

Compared to the aforementioned meteorites, Y-791824-84 is signficantly more altered, which is consistent with analysis conducted by Kojima et al. (1984) (see Table 1). The degree of alteration is likely inbetween that of Murchison (CM2.5) and Nogoya (CM2.2), which indicates that Y-791824 could potentially be classified as a CM2.3-2.4. This is if we assume that the fragments of Murchison and Nogoya are representative of the sections studied by Rubin et al. (2007).

Interestingly, Y-791824 is particularly rich in Ca-carbonates. Compared to all other CM chondrites that I have viewed in the RELAB database, this feature (or, at least, its intensity) is unique to any other member. As such, I wonder whether the mineralogy of this meteorite prior to weathering was distinct from other CMs. If so, it could potentially question the classification of Y-791824 as a “typical” CM chondrite. Petrographic and geochemical assesment would be required to verify this.

Acknowledgement

This research utilizes spectra acquired by Takahiro Hiroi, Seiji Sugita and Jessica M. Sunshine with the NASA RELAB facility at Brown University. Access can be found here.

Note: The work presented in this blog post is independent of previously unpublished or ongoing research.

References

Chizmadia, L. J., & Brearley, A. J. (2008). Mineralogy, aqueous alteration, and primitive textural characteristics of fine-grained rims in the Y-791198 CM2 carbonaceous chondrite: TEM observations and comparison to ALHA81002. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 72(2), 602-625.

Ikeda, Y. (1992). An overview of the research consortium,” Antarctic carbonaceouschondrites with CI affinities, Yamato-86720, Yamato-82162, andBelgica-7904. In Proceedings of the NIPR Symposium on Antarctic Meteorites (Vol. 5, pp. 49-73). National Institute of Polar Research.

King, A. J., Bates, H. C., Krietsch, D., Busemann, H., Clay, P. L., Schofield, P. F., & Russell, S. S. (2019). The Yamato-type (CY) carbonaceous chondrite group: Analogues for the surface of asteroid Ryugu?. Geochemistry, 79(4), 125531.

King, A. J., Mason, E., Bates, H. C., Schofield, P. F., Donaldson Hanna, K. L., Bowles, N. E., & Russell, S. S. (2021). Tracing the earliest stages of hydrothermal alteration on the CM chondrite parent body. Meteoritics & Planetary Science, 56(9), 1708-1728.

Kojima, H., Ikeda, Y., & Yanai, K. (1984). The alteration of chondrules and matrices in new Antarctic carbonaceous chondrites. Memoirs of National Institute of Polar Research. Special issue, 35, 184-199.

Rubin, A. E., Trigo-Rodríguez, J. M., Huber, H., & Wasson, J. T. (2007). Progressive aqueous alteration of CM carbonaceous chondrites. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 71(9), 2361-2382.

Suttle, M. D., Daly, L., Jones, R. H., Jenkins, L., Van Ginneken, M., Mitchell, J. T., … & Dignam, A. (2022). The Winchcombe meteorite—A regolith breccia from a rubble pile CM chondrite asteroid. Meteoritics & Planetary Science.

The post-accretional history of DOM 10121, a recently-classified CM2 Chondrite

This blog post looks into the secondary history of Dominion Range (DOM) 10121, a “new” CM chondrite that currently lacks detailed mineralogical and petrographic investigation. A such, the post-accretional (secondary history) is not yet well-studied. Based on my personal analysis of available online data, I suspect DOM 10121 may potentially have been a midly heated and/or a relatively mildly altered CM2. Further analysis is required to confirm (or reject) my conclusions.

Fig. 1: DOM 10121 at the location of its discovery. Image credit: Meteoritical Society database.

Dominion Range (DOM) 10121 is a small 16.15 g meteorite recovered by the ANSMET team during their 2010 expedition (Fig. 1). Although initially classified as an Ornans-type (CO) chondrite (Meteoritical Bulletin), it was recently reclassified as a being a Mighei-type (CM) member (Righter et al., 2024). CMs tend to be aqueously altered, although to various extents. Indeed, some CMs are highly primitive (Kimura et al., 2020) while some have been almost completely altered into hydrated phases (e.g. Fe-Mg serpentine). Others have undergone thermal events that resulted in the modification of its mineralogy (e.g. decomposition and recrystallization of serpentine into olivine). Such events may possibly be due to high velocity impacts or solar radiation.

Firstly, I looked at the degree of aqueous alteration. In CMs, (Fe-Mg) serpentine forms at the expense of its initial anhydrous silicate mineralogy. As serpentine replaces chondrules, its bulk Mg/Fe content increases, as chondrules predominantly contain Mg-rich olivine and enstatite. The increase in serpentine and its Mg content can be traced through Mid-Infrared spectroscopy (e.g. Beck et al., 2010). Indeed, between 13 and 25 µm absorption bands from Mg-rich serpentine and anhydrous silicates (e.g. olivine and enstatite) occur, among other. With progressive alteration, the “smooth” absorption bands due to Mg-rich serpentine increase and override the anhydrous silicates (i.e. become more difficult to distinguish). Here I compare a publicly available spectrum of a DOM 10121 chip (split fragment 11) with those of other CMs (unheated ones: Fig.2).

Fig. 2: MIR spectra of a chip of DOM 10121-11 in comparison to those of other CM chondrites. The “Mg-rich serpentine” is in fact a spectrum of ALH 84044, a highly altered CM. Such CMs have elevated serpentine Mg/Fe ratios. All spectra are from the RELAB database.

The spectrum of DOM 10121-11 lacks noticeable anhydrous silicate signatures at ~15 µm, with only serpentine apparent (as also observed in Y-791198-101 and Murchison). The ~19.5 µm anhydrous silicate band is comparable to Y-791198-101 and LAP 04796-9. To the naked eye, Y-791198-101 is the best spectral match for DOM 10121-11. This is interesting considering that Y-791198 has been described as mildly altered by some studies (e.g. Chizmadia et al., 2008), although slightly more altered than Murchison in others (Rubin et al., 2007). LAP 04796 is also another mildly altered CM2 (King et al., 2021a). If we consider our fragment Murchison a CM2.5 (as described in Rubin et al., 2007) and LAP 04796-9 a CM2.6 (based on King et al., 2021), then DOM 10121-11 and Y-791198-101 should be CM2.5/2.6.

I also compared the spectra of DOM 10121-11 with heated CM2s: EET 96029(-54) and two fragments of Jbilet Winselwan (Fig. 3). The spectrum of DOM 10121-11 looks more alike the unheated CMs compared to these heated ones. “Typical” Mg-rich serpentine signatures (e.g. the 15-µm band) are not obvious in EET 96029-54 and Jbilet Winselwan, suggesting that any Mg-rich serpentine did not persist after heating. I suspect that sulfates signatures are likely a product of terrestrial weathering, rather than thermal metamorphism.

Fig. 3: MIR spectra of a chip of DOM 10121-11 in comparison to heated CM chondrites (Stage-II). The “Mg-rich serpentine” is in fact a spectrum of ALH 84044, a highly altered CM. Such CMs have elevated serpentine Mg/Fe ratios. All spectra are from the RELAB database.  

Although the MIR spectra do not show evidence of significant post-aqueous heating, geochemical data from Righter et al. (2024) might suggest otherwise. Indeed, the DOM 10121 dH and H values compared to those of Alexander et al. (2013) are comparable to those of heated CMs. Considering that hydrogen in CMs is predominantly present in phyllosilicates, this would suggest that (Fe-Mg) serpentine may have been mildly dehydrated. Considering that Mg-rich serpentine is still intact (Fig. 1 and 2), this might mean that temperatures did not exceed 600°C (from memory based on the thesis of Garenne, 2014). Fe-rich serpentine decompose at lower temperatures, meaning that these may have been affected (there is no way of knowing without more data). Alternatively, as CMs tend to be breccia, DOM 10121-11 may have escaped heating, unlike the sample studied by Righter et al. (2024). The values suggest the same for DOM 10299, which is paired with DOM 10121 (Righter et al., 2024).

Fig. 4: Bulk composition and quantity of hydrogen of DOM 10121 and DOM 10299 compared to heated and unheated CMs. Values from Alexander et al.(2013) and Righter et al. 2024).

To further verify the possibility that DOM 10121 may have been heated, I looked at petrographic images available online (here). Indeed, Mouti Al-Hashimi et al. (2023) studied the fine-grained rims (FGRs) of CMs and noted that radial fractures develop with recurrent heating. They suggested that this is due to dehydration of phyllosilicates within the FGRs. Based on the images online (which are occasionally of low resolution), radial fractures in FGRs were found around a couple or a few chondrules in DOM 10121, as well as in its paired sample, DOM10299 (likely more in the latter: Fig. 5). This might possibly indicate a degree of phyllosilicate dehydration, thus consistent with the data in Fig. 4.

Fig. 5: Compilation of various chondrules surrounded by fine-grained rims, plus radial fractures, including DOM 10121 and DOM 10299. The exception is one WIS 91608 image showing an example of a chondrule FGR without radial cracks. PCA 91008 is a well-known stage III/IV heated CM chondrite, while WIS 91608 is paired with the Stage-II heated carbonaceous chondrite WIS 91600. LEW 85307 is paired with LEW 85311 and LEW 85312 which has not been reported as heated based on Rama data. This does not necessary exclude LEW 85307 as having been heated, as heating may have been heterogenous within the meteoroid. Scale is omitted. Images extracted and modified from the Meteoritical Society database.

For comparison, I looked at other CMs (unheated and heated) to see whether this could be used to discriminate between heated and unheated samples using these images alone. Indeed, they were difficult to detect in most unheated CMs, as well as in some mildly heated CMs (ALH 84033, EET 87522 and MAC 88100). Other, more heated CMs, notably PCA 91008 and PCA 02050, are quite rich in FGR radial fractures. Unfortunately, due to the variable scale, clarity and resolution of the images on the Meteoritical Socity database interface, it is often difficult to be certain in the case of many samples. Despite that, their presence in DOM 10121 and DOM10299 may be in support the heating hypothesis. Hence, depending on whether the Fe-Mg serpentine have remained fully intact or not, DOM 10121 could qualify as a Stage-I or Stage-II heated CM2 (see King et al., 2021b).

Conclusion:

DOM 10121 may be a post-aqueously heated CM2 chondrite, possibly of Stage-I or II. Alternatively, if heating did not take place, then it may qualify as a relatively mildly altered CM2.5/2.6 chondrite (hence less altered than most). Due to the low number and quality of data, further investigation is required to confirm or reject my interpretations (e.g. XRD or IR and raman spectroscopy).

References:

Alexander, C. M. D., Howard, K. T., Bowden, R., & Fogel, M. L. (2013). The classification of CM and CR chondrites using bulk H, C and N abundances and isotopic compositions. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 123, 244-260.

Beck, P., Quirico, E., Montes-Hernandez, G., Bonal, L., Bollard, J., Orthous-Daunay, F. R., … & Guillot, S. (2010). Hydrous mineralogy of CM and CI chondrites from infrared spectroscopy and their relationship with low albedo asteroids. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 74(16), 4881-4892.

Chizmadia, L. J., & Brearley, A. J. (2008). Mineralogy, aqueous alteration, and primitive textural characteristics of fine-grained rims in the Y-791198 CM2 carbonaceous chondrite: TEM observations and comparison to ALHA81002. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 72(2), 602-625.

Thesis of Alexandre Garenne (2014) on Theses.fr: https://www.theses.fr/2014GRENU054

King, A. J., Schofield, P. F., & Russell, S. S. (2021a). Thermal alteration of CM carbonaceous chondrites: Mineralogical changes and metamorphic temperatures. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 298, 167-190.

King, A. J., Mason, E., Bates, H. C., Schofield, P. F., Donaldson Hanna, K. L., Bowles, N. E., & Russell, S. S. (2021b). Tracing the earliest stages of hydrothermal alteration on the CM chondrite parent body. Meteoritics & Planetary Science, 56(9), 1708-1728.

Krietsch, D., Busemann, H., Riebe, M. E., King, A. J., Alexander, C. M. D., & Maden, C. (2021). Noble gases in CM carbonaceous chondrites: Effect of parent body aqueous and thermal alteration and cosmic ray exposure ages. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 310, 240-280.

Mouti Al‐Hashimi, X., Davidson, J., Schrader, D. L., & Bullock, E. S. (2023). Fine‐grained chondrule rims in Mighei‐like carbonaceous chondrites: Evidence for a nebular origin and modification by impacts and recurrent solar radiation heating. Meteoritics & Planetary Science.

Quirico, E., Bonal, L., Beck, P., Yabuta, H., Nakamura, T., Nakato, A., … & Herd, C. D. K. (2018). Prevalence and nature of heating processes in CM and C2-ungrouped chondrites as revealed by insoluble organic matter. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 241, 17-37.

Righter, K., Alexander, C. O. D., Foustoukos, D. I., Eckart, L. M., Mertens, C. A. K., Busemann, H., … & Karner, J. (2024). Pairing relations within CO3 chondrites recovered at the Dominion Range and Miller Range, Transantarctic mountains: Constraints from chondrule olivines, noble gas, and H, C, N bulk and isotopic compositions. Meteoritics & Planetary Science.

A New Bright Sungrazing Comet Discovered by SOHO!

On December 12th, a bright sungrazing comet met its demise. The rise and fall of this comet was followed by the coronagraphs aboard the SOHO and STEREO-A spacecraft. The comet may have reached close to mag +0 at its best, making it among the brightest sungrazers discovered by SOHO.

Fig. 1: The demise of the bright Kreutz-group comet as observed by the SOHO/LASCO C2 camera. Notice how remains of its debris trail are pushed away by the solar wind. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO LASCO C2.

On December 9th, SOHO comet hunter Jiangao Ruan reported an obvious comet entering the SOHO/LASCO C3 FOV. The trajectory showed that it was of the Kreutz-II subgroup, which includes some of the brightest reported comets (e.g. C/1882 R1 and C/1965 S1: Fig. 2). Admittedly, this comet was a significantly fainter (i.e. smaller) fragment, as supported by the fact that it had escaped detection by ground-based surveys and amateur comet hunters.

Fig. 2: Comet C/1965 S1 (Ikeya-Seki), a very bright example of the Kreutz-II group member. Image extracted from Wikipedia, but originally taken by James W. Young (TMO/JPL/NASA).

Despite this, the comet was a significantly brighter-than-average Kreutz. More specifically, it is very rare that a Kreutz is observed entering the C3 FOV during this time of the year. In fact, I have personally never seen a Kreutz as bright as this one within this region of the C3 field (with the excption of C/2011 W3: Fig. 3).

Fig. 3: The new Kreutz (left) and C/2011 W3 (right) as seen shortly after entering the SOHO/LASCO C3 FOV. Although clearly detectable, the new comet was significantly fainter than C/2011 W3 at this stage in its orbit. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO/LASCO C3.

The comet brightened nicely over the next couple of days, but around midday on December 11th it started declining in brightness, marking the disintegration of the comet. This is sadly the fate of all SOHO-discovered Kreutz-group comets (at least, so far). The comet was also observed by STEREO-A (Fig. 4), both in its COR2-A and COR1-A imagers.

Fig. 4: The demise of the bright Kreutz-group comet as observed by the STEREO/SECCHI COR2-A camera. Much like in SOHO/LASCO images, the remains of its debris trail are apparent after the comet’s disappearance. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO LASCO C2.

By visual comparison with C/1996 Y1 (SOHO-6), it seems likely that this sungrazer reached a maximum magnitude within the same range (Fig. 5). According to the values published on the website of Rainer Kracht, SOHO-6 reached an apparent mag of +0, although I assume the brightness was slightly enhanced by forward scattering. By extension, this comet possibly reached a maximum apparent brightness of +0 mag.

Fig. 5: Comparison between SOHO-6 (left) and the new Kreutz (right) soon after entering SOHO/LASCO C2. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO LASCO C2.

Overall, other than SOHO-6, the morphology of this new sungrazer was similar to those of other bright SOHO/STEREO-discovered comets, such as STEREO-23 and SOHO-4119 (Fig. 6). Indeed, its brightness and debris trail were signficantly less remarkable than that of C/2011 W3 (Lovejoy). This shows that the new Kreutz is no unique object, but rather an “ordinary” Kreutz with a more-than-average brightness.

Fig. 6: Comparison between the new sungrazer, C/2009 Y4 (STEREO-23), SOHO-4119 and C/2011 W3 (Lovejoy) soon after entering SOHO/LASCO C2. The last of these is significantly brighter than the others. Image credit: ESA/NASA SOHO LASCO C2.

References: with the exception of the sources listed the text, this blog post is based on my own interpretations of publicly available SOHO/LASCO and STEREO/SECCHI-A images. Note that the “Kreutz-II” nature of this sungrazer was pointed out by Robert Pickard.